Skip to content
Sigilock

Comparison

Sigilock vs Private Photo Vault: a veteran vault against a newcomer

Private Photo Vault has been around since 2011, with ads, a cloud option and many tools. Sigilock has no ads or tracking. Features, privacy and prices compared.

By , founder of SigilockFacts about Private Photo Vault checked on October 25, 202610 min read

The short answer

Private Photo Vault is one of the oldest vaults, with an iPad app, its own encrypted cloud and a long list of tools. Sigilock has no ads or tracking, puts its decoys and duress mode in the free plan, and publishes how it encrypts your files. Choose by what matters more: features and sync, or privacy by default.

Private Photo Vault, published by Legendary Software Labs in Las Vegas, first appeared on the App Store in 2011. It has around a million ratings on the US App Store and more than 10 million downloads on Google Play, which makes it one of the most established vaults there is. Sigilock is much newer and smaller, and built on different priorities. Both keep an encrypted vault on your phone with no account required; they differ on ads, the cloud, decoys and how much they tell you about their encryption. This page uses Private Photo Vault’s App Store listing, its Google Play page and its own website as the sources for everything we say about it.

At a glance

Sigilock and Private Photo Vault compared
FeaturePrivate Photo VaultSigilock
iPhone
iPad
Android
No account for the vault on the phone
Cloud backupIts own Cloud Vault, PremiumYour own iCloud or Google Drive, optional
Sync between iPhone and AndroidCloud Vault, Premium
Unlock withPIN, password or pattern; Face ID, Touch ID or fingerprintPattern on a 5×5 grid or numeric code; Face ID or fingerprint for one vault
Decoy vaultOne alternate vaultOne per pattern, free
Duress modeFree
Failed attemptsBreak-in report with photo and GPSLog of attempts, free
Disguised app iconCustom iconsCalculator or notes, free
What it storesPhotos and videosPhotos, videos, notes and files
Shared vaultsPremium to create
Private web browser
No ads in the free version

What the free plan includes

Private Photo Vault is free to download and shows ads. Its Google Play listing names the Premium features: album locks, break-in alerts, the Fake PIN decoy vault, Cloud Vault with up to 50 GB, Space Saver, custom album covers and the removal of ads. Its App Store listing doesn’t say which features are paid, apart from Cloud Vault. Neither store states how many photos the free version holds. Its FAQ adds that if Premium ends, your photos stay in the app but your cloud backup is deleted.

Sigilock’s free plan holds 2 vaults with up to 25 items each, shows no ads, and includes every privacy feature: decoy vaults, duress mode, the intruder log, the calculator and notes icons and encrypted backup. Premium removes the limits and lets you create shared vaults.

Prices

Private Photo Vault’s store listings show prices without saying how long each plan lasts, which makes a period-by-period table impossible. Here is what each listing shows, from the France App Store in euros unless stated, on the date at the top of this page.

Premium prices on the App Store
FeaturePrivate Photo VaultSigilock Premium
Featured plan7,99 € ($6.99 in the US), with a free trial; period not shown22,99 € a year
Other purchases listedFrom 7,99 € to 59,99 €; periods not shown1,99 € a week, 49 € lifetime
Free trialYes, on the featured planNone

On Google Play, Private Photo Vault lists in-app purchases from $2.99 to $179.99 per item. The app itself shows the current plans before you pay, so check there. Sigilock’s plans and prices are on the pricing section; it has no trial because its free plan already includes every privacy feature.

How each one protects your photos

Private Photo Vault’s security page says that “files stored in the app use AES encryption”, and its FAQ says AES-256. It doesn’t say which mode is used or how your PIN becomes a key for the vault on your phone. The page also notes that it is “product documentation, not an independent security audit”, which is a fair point to make about any vault, Sigilock included.

Sigilock encrypts every file, thumbnail and index with AES-256-GCM, an authenticated mode that also detects tampering. Your pattern becomes a key through Argon2id, mixed with a secret kept in the iPhone Keychain or Android Keystore. The security page explains each step, and AES-256 encryption explains what it means for your files.

Security and recovery compared
FeaturePrivate Photo VaultSigilock
Files on the phoneAES, AES-256 per its FAQAES-256-GCM, authenticated
Code to key on the phoneNot publishedArgon2id, about 0.7 s and 64 MiB
Cloud backupExtra AES-256 layer, key from a Cloud Vault password via Argon2idFiles go up already encrypted; restored with the recovery phrase
Forgotten app codeRecovery email, if you set one up12-word recovery phrase
Forgotten cloud password“Never recoverable”No separate cloud password

For the code on your phone, Private Photo Vault relies on a recovery email you can set up when you first use the app; without one, its FAQ says the app and album passwords can’t be recovered. Sigilock gives each vault a 12-word recovery phrase instead, which works without any email or server, as long as you keep it safe.

The cloud: Cloud Vault or your own account

Private Photo Vault keeps your vault on the phone by default and says its cloud backup isn’t automatic. Its optional Cloud Vault, on Premium, needs an account and stores your files on its servers. It describes it as zero-knowledge: your files get another layer of AES-256 encryption on the phone, with a key made from a Cloud Vault password through Argon2id that “is never uploaded to our servers”. Cloud Vault syncs your vault between iPhone and Android, and Space Saver keeps the originals in the cloud to free up space.

Sigilock has no cloud of its own. Each vault can be backed up, if you choose, to your own iCloud on iPhone or a hidden folder in your own Google Drive on Android, already encrypted, and a new phone needs only the vault’s recovery phrase to restore it. It is free, but it doesn’t keep two devices in sync. Neither app has a web version: Private Photo Vault says plainly that “there is no browser login” (source), and Sigilock’s vaults only open in the app.

Decoys, intruders and disguises

Both apps can show a decoy. Private Photo Vault’s decoy password opens one alternate vault instead of your main collection; Google Play lists it as a Premium feature, Fake PIN. In Sigilock every pattern opens its own vault, free, and a duress mode goes further: you choose a harmless vault as the duress vault, and opening it removes the other vaults’ patterns from the phone. They stay encrypted and come back with their recovery phrases.

Private Photo Vault doesn’t document a duress action, but it has two locks Sigilock doesn’t: Face Down Lock, which locks the app when you turn the phone over, and Location Based Lock, which blocks the vault in places you choose. Its Break-in Report records attempts with a photo of the intruder and their location. Sigilock’s intruder log records each failed attempt and when it happened, without photos or location, so it needs neither permission.

For the icon, Private Photo Vault offers custom icons with “more discreet” choices. Sigilock offers a calculator icon and a notes icon, free on iPhone and Android, and its privacy shield blocks screenshots and hides the vault in the app switcher.

Privacy: ads and data collected

Private Photo Vault’s free version shows ads. Its App Store privacy label lists Usage Data under “Data Used to Track You”, and purchases, user content, identifiers, usage data and diagnostics as data linked to you. Its privacy policy names advertising networks including AdMob, Unity Ads and AppLovin, says it may share your device ID or IP address with marketing partners to show targeted ads, and states that your photos and videos are never shared with them. Its Google Play data safety section says it may share device IDs for analytics and advertising.

Sigilock shows no ads and contains no analytics, crash reporting or advertising SDKs, on any plan. How Sigilock avoids tracking lists the only things that ever leave your phone: purchases, through Apple or Google, and anything you choose to share or back up, encrypted.

Where Private Photo Vault is better

  • More devices. iPhone, iPad and Android, and the iPad app also runs on Apple-silicon Macs.
  • Cloud sync. Cloud Vault keeps your vault in sync between iPhone and Android, with Space Saver.
  • Many more tools. A private browser, photo and video editors, duplicate detection, Wi-Fi transfer and per-album passwords.
  • Intruder photos and location. A picture of whoever tried to get in, and where.
  • Location and face-down locks. The vault can lock itself in places you choose or when the phone is turned over.
  • A long track record. On the App Store since 2011, with around a million ratings.

Where Sigilock is better

  • No ads and no tracking. No advertising networks, analytics or crash reporting, on any plan.
  • Every privacy feature for free. Decoys, duress mode, the intruder log and disguised icons.
  • Duress mode. A harmless vault that, once opened, locks the others away.
  • More than photos. Encrypted notes and files sit in the same vault.
  • Shared vaults. Share a vault that stays encrypted, opens free and expires on its own.
  • Published cryptography. AES-256-GCM and Argon2id for the vault on your phone, explained in full.

Switching from Private Photo Vault to Sigilock

  1. Install Sigilock and draw a sigil for your first vault. Write down its 12-word recovery phrase.
  2. In Private Photo Vault, select the photos and videos you want to move and export them to your phone’s photo library.
  3. In Sigilock, tap Add and pick them. On iPhone, turn on Remove originals after import first and Sigilock offers to delete the copies; on Android, delete them in your gallery app yourself.
  4. Empty Recently Deleted (iPhone) or the trash in Google Photos (Android), so no copies stay behind.
  5. Once everything is moved, cancel any Private Photo Vault subscription in the App Store or Google Play, and delete its Cloud Vault backup if you used one.
  6. Our guides for iPhone and Android have more tips for leaving no copies behind.

Frequently asked questions

Who makes Private Photo Vault?

Legendary Software Labs LLC, a company in Las Vegas, Nevada. The app has been on the App Store since 2011 and runs on iPhone, iPad and Android.

Does Private Photo Vault need an account?

Not for the vault on your phone. Its Cloud Vault backup, a Premium feature, needs an account. Sigilock never needs one, even for backups, which go to your own iCloud or Google Drive.

Does Private Photo Vault show ads?

Yes, in the free version; Premium removes them. Its privacy policy names ad networks such as AdMob, Unity Ads and AppLovin. Sigilock shows no ads and has no analytics or tracking on any plan.

Is Private Photo Vault encrypted?

It says files in the app use AES encryption, AES-256 according to its FAQ, and that Cloud Vault adds another AES-256 layer before upload. Sigilock uses AES-256-GCM with keys derived from your pattern through Argon2id, and publishes the full design.

Which one has a decoy vault?

Both. Private Photo Vault’s decoy password opens one alternate vault, listed as Premium on Google Play. In Sigilock every pattern opens its own vault for free, and a duress vault can also lock the others away.

What happens if I forget my code?

Private Photo Vault can recover the app password through a recovery email if you set one up; its Cloud Vault password can never be recovered. Sigilock opens each vault again with its 12-word recovery phrase.

Can I store notes or documents?

Private Photo Vault is made for photos and videos. Sigilock also keeps encrypted notes and files in the same vaults as your photos.

How do I move my photos from Private Photo Vault to Sigilock?

Export them from Private Photo Vault to your photo library, add them to a Sigilock vault, then delete the library copies and empty the trash. On iPhone, Sigilock can delete the copies for you.

Sources

Where the facts about each app on this page come from: their store listings, websites and policies, as checked on the date above.

  1. 1.App Store: Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe
  2. 2.Google Play: Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe
  3. 3.Google Play: Private Photo Vault data safety
  4. 4.Private Photo Vault: Privacy & security
  5. 5.Private Photo Vault: FAQ
  6. 6.Private Photo Vault: Cloud Vault
  7. 7.Private Photo Vault: Decoy password
  8. 8.Private Photo Vault: Break-in report
  9. 9.Private Photo Vault: Location based lock
  10. 10.Private Photo Vault: Custom icons & appearance
  11. 11.Private Photo Vault: Private web browser
  12. 12.Private Photo Vault: Photo vault online
  13. 13.Private Photo Vault: Privacy policy