A calculator vault app is a photo vault disguised as a calculator. Its icon and name say Calculator, it opens on a calculator that really calculates, and the vault only appears when you type a secret code and press equals. There are many of them, especially on Android, from many different developers, and they vary a lot in quality. Rather than compare Sigilock with all of them, this page explains how the category works, using two well-known examples and an academic study, and shows where Sigilock takes a different approach.
The two examples are Calculator# by NewSoftwares, available on iPhone, iPad and Android, and HideU by Amber Mobile Limited, an Android app with more than 100 million downloads on Google Play. Everything we say about them comes from their own store listings.
At a glance
| Feature | Calculator# | HideU | Sigilock |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phones | iPhone, iPad and Android | Android | iPhone and Android |
| Looks like a calculator | Icon, name and first screen | Icon, name and first screen | Icon only; the name stays Sigilock |
| Opens with | A code on the calculator, or Face ID, PIN, pattern or password | A password on the calculator, then = | A pattern on a 5×5 grid or a numeric code |
| Encryption named in the listing | AES-256-GCM, Argon2id | ||
| Forgotten code | Sent to your registered email | Type 11223344= and answer a security question | 12-word recovery phrase |
| Decoy | Decoy Mode on Android | Not documented | One vault per pattern |
| Duress mode | |||
| Failed attempts | Logged; photo on Android | Not documented | Logged |
| No ads in the free version | |||
| Price | 4,99 € a year | In-app purchases, $0.99 to $9.99 | Free plan; Premium 22,99 € a year |
How the disguise works
The idea is simple: if nobody knows there is a vault, nobody asks you to open it. HideU’s listing explains that its icon “looks like an ordinary system calculator, and you can also use it to perform calculations”, and that you “enter your password on calculator and press ‘=’ button to open”. Calculator# works the same way and adds a Panic Switch that jumps to another app, plus a fake crash message on iPhone to put off anyone who tries.
Against a quick look at your home screen, this is effective. A calculator is the most ordinary app there is, and someone scrolling through your phone has no reason to try typing codes into it. That is the real strength of the category, and Sigilock doesn’t match it: its alternate icon changes the picture, but the name under the icon stays Sigilock and the app opens on its pattern screen, not on a working calculator.
When the disguise is known
The weakness of a disguise is that it only works while it is a secret. In 2022, researchers at the University of Illinois analysed 20 popular Android vault apps, including calculator-style ones, in a peer-reviewed study presented at the ACM Workshop on Privacy in the Electronic Society. They found that 17 of the 20 showed a different name or icon in the phone’s list of apps than on the home screen, and that the better-disguised ones could still give themselves away through their unusually large size. Their conclusion was that most could be identified without any technical skill.
The same study found that files could be retrieved without rooting the phone for 15 of the 20 apps, and only 5 of the 20 attempted to encrypt the files at all. It looked at the versions available in 2022 and doesn’t name every app, so it doesn’t tell you how a particular app behaves today. It does show why a disguise alone is not protection: once someone knows where to look, what matters is whether the files are properly encrypted.
Neither of our two examples names an encryption method in its store listing. Calculator#’s Google Play data safety section says data isn’t encrypted in transit, and so does HideU’s. That doesn’t prove the files themselves aren’t encrypted on the phone; it means the listings don’t say.
Sigilock’s approach: assume the vault is found
Sigilock is designed for the moment the disguise fails. Every file, thumbnail and index is encrypted with AES-256-GCM, with keys derived from your pattern through Argon2id and a secret kept in the iPhone Keychain or Android Keystore, as the security page explains. Copying the app’s data off the phone gives an attacker encrypted files and nothing else.
For the moment someone makes you open the app, Sigilock gives every pattern its own vault, so a decoy vault opens as convincingly as the real one. Its duress mode goes further: open the vault you chose as the duress vault, and the other vaults’ patterns are removed from the phone, so nobody can open them there, not even you, until you restore them with their recovery phrases. The intruder log tells you afterwards how many wrong patterns were tried, and when.
A disguise and a lock aren’t mutually exclusive. Sigilock still offers a calculator and a notes icon, free, and its hidden trail lets you draw without showing the pattern on screen. On recent iPhones you can also hide an app in a hidden folder of the App Library, Sigilock included.
Recovery and backups
Forgetting the code is where calculator apps differ most. Calculator# lets you retrieve a lost password through your registered email; on Android, tapping + five times on the calculator emails you the lost PIN. HideU asks you to type 11223344= and answer a security question, or to email support. Sigilock creates a 12-word recovery phrase for each vault: no email and no special key sequence, but you have to keep the phrase somewhere safe, away from the phone.
HideU’s listing warns: “Do not uninstall HideU, clear app data or delete files and folders generated by HideU before backing up your personal data through cloud service. Otherwise, your files will be lost forever.” That is true of any vault that keeps your files on the phone, Sigilock included. Calculator# backs up to iCloud, Dropbox, Google Drive or OneDrive; Sigilock’s optional encrypted backup goes to your own iCloud or Google Drive, already encrypted, and a new phone needs only the vault’s recovery phrase to restore it.
Ads and tracking
Most calculator vault apps are free with ads: 13 of the top 14 results we checked in a Google Play search were marked as containing ads. Both examples are: Calculator# says it “is free with ads and limitations”, and HideU’s Google Play page says it contains ads. Calculator#’s App Store privacy label lists contact info under “Data Used to Track You”. HideU’s data safety section says it may share user IDs, app interactions, device IDs and crash logs, for analytics and, for some of them, advertising.
Sigilock shows no ads and contains no analytics, crash reporting or advertising SDKs, on any plan. How Sigilock avoids tracking lists the only things that ever leave your phone.
Where calculator vault apps are better
- A full disguise. The name, the icon and the first screen all say calculator; Sigilock only changes the icon.
- A working calculator. Someone who opens it sees an ordinary app and can even use it.
- Price. Calculator# costs 4,99 € a year, against 22,99 € for Sigilock Premium.
- Extra tools. Private browsers, app locks, password managers and Wi-Fi transfer, depending on the app.
- Intruder photos. Calculator# on Android takes a picture of whoever enters a wrong code.
- iPad. Calculator# also runs on iPad; Sigilock doesn’t yet.
Where Sigilock is better
- Protection that survives discovery. Encryption with published details, not a disguise alone.
- Decoys and duress. A vault per pattern and a duress vault that locks the others away, all in the free plan.
- Recovery without email. A 12-word phrase instead of an address or a code anyone could look up.
- No ads and no tracking. Nothing in the app reports what you do.
- Screen privacy. The privacy shield blocks screenshots and hides the vault in the app switcher.
Which should you choose?
If your main worry is someone glancing at your home screen, and they don’t know calculator vaults exist, a well-made calculator app may be all you need; choose one that says clearly how it encrypts your files and how you recover them. If the people you want to keep out may know the trick, may look through your phone properly, or may make you unlock it, choose a vault built for that, with real encryption, decoys and a duress mode. Not sure? Our comparison with the built-in options and the guides for iPhone and Android cover the free options too.