Skip to content
Sigilock

Comparison

Sigilock vs Keepsafe: an account-free vault against a cloud-backed one

Keepsafe backs your vault up to its own cloud behind an email account; Sigilock needs no account. Prices, privacy, decoys and recovery compared.

By , founder of SigilockFacts about Keepsafe checked on October 25, 202611 min read

The short answer

Keepsafe is a long-established vault built around an email account and its own cloud, which makes sync and recovery easy. Sigilock needs no account and keeps everything on your phone. Choose Keepsafe for iPad, cloud sync and intruder photos; choose Sigilock for no account, no ads and a free duress mode.

Keepsafe is one of the best-known photo vaults. It started in San Francisco in 2012, lists more than 50 million downloads on Google Play, and runs on iPhone, iPad and Android. Sigilock is a much younger app with a different design: no account, no developer cloud and no ads. Both lock your photos and videos behind a code and encrypt them on the phone, but they make opposite choices about accounts and the cloud. This page compares them point by point, using Keepsafe’s App Store listing, its Google Play page and its help centre as the sources for everything we say about it.

At a glance

Sigilock and Keepsafe compared
FeatureKeepsafeSigilock
iPhone
iPad
Android
Account neededEmail, verifiedNone
Cloud backupKeepsafe’s own cloud, optionalYour own iCloud or Google Drive, optional
Sync between devices
Unlock withPIN, pattern on Android, Face ID or fingerprintPattern on a 5×5 grid or numeric code; Face ID or fingerprint for one vault
Decoy vaultOne, PremiumOne per pattern, free
Duress modeFree
Failed attemptsIntruder photos, PremiumLog of attempts, free
Disguised app iconAndroid only, PremiumCalculator or notes, free
Shared albums or vaultsPremium to create
PDFs and documentsPDFsNotes and files
No ads in the free version

Account and cloud: the main difference

Keepsafe is built around an account. Its setup guide starts with “create your Keepsafe login”: you enter a name and an email address and verify it, and logging in on a new phone uses a code sent to that address. The account is what lets Keepsafe back your vault up to its own “private Keepsafe cloud”, sync it across all your devices, and reset your PIN by email.

The cloud backup is optional, but Keepsafe strongly encourages it. Its help centre also explains who can see what. On whether Keepsafe can see your content, it says that it does not look at your files unless you ask, and that “Keepsafe is not currently designed as a completely zero-knowledge app”: staff can technically access your data when you ask for support, when the law requires it, or if they suspect a breach of their terms.

Sigilock makes the opposite choice. There is no account, no email and no Sigilock server holding your photos. Everything is encrypted on the phone, and the optional encrypted backup goes to your own iCloud or Google Drive already encrypted, and a new phone needs only the vault’s recovery phrase to restore it. Nobody at Sigilock can open your vaults, because we never have the keys. The trade-off is that there is no automatic sync between devices and no email reset if you forget your pattern.

What the free plan includes

Keepsafe’s free version, Keepsafe Basic, is ad-supported. According to its backup article, Basic users can back up 200 items to Keepsafe’s cloud; Premium raises that to 10,000 items, or 100,000 with the Lifetime plan. The decoy vault, intruder alerts, album passwords, Secret Door, Space Saver and the removal of ads are all Premium features. Every new account starts with a 30-day Premium trial.

Sigilock’s free plan holds 2 vaults with up to 25 items each and shows no ads. It includes every privacy feature: decoy vaults, duress mode, the intruder log, the calculator and notes icons and encrypted backup. Premium removes the limits and lets you create shared vaults. So Keepsafe Basic stores more, and Sigilock’s free plan protects more.

Prices

Prices below are from each app’s France App Store listing, in euros, on the date at the top of this page. Keepsafe also lists other Premium purchases on the store without saying what they include, so only its labelled plans are shown.

Premium prices on the App Store in France
FeatureKeepsafe PremiumSigilock Premium
WeeklyNot offered1,99 €
Monthly10,99 €Not offered
Annual26,49 €22,99 €
LifetimeOffered, price not listed49 €
Free trial30 days for new accountsNone
Ads on the free versionYesNo

In the US App Store, Keepsafe lists $9.99 a month and $23.99 a year. Sigilock’s annual plan is a little cheaper, and its lifetime price is shown up front. Keepsafe’s trial lets you try Premium for a month; Sigilock has no trial because its free plan already includes every privacy feature. See Sigilock’s pricing for the details.

How each one protects your photos

Keepsafe says its files are protected “using the industry-standard 256-bit AES encryption”, that “all files are encrypted at rest”, and that its backups are encrypted too (How does Keepsafe protect my data?). It doesn’t publish the cipher mode or how your PIN becomes a key. After too many wrong PINs, it blocks further attempts for a while.

Sigilock encrypts every file, thumbnail and index with AES-256-GCM, which also detects tampering. Your pattern becomes a key through Argon2id, a memory-hard function that makes guessing slow and costly, mixed with a secret kept in the iPhone Keychain or Android Keystore. The security page explains each step, and AES-256 encryption explains what it means for your files.

Security and recovery compared
FeatureKeepsafeSigilock
File encryptionAES-256, mode not publishedAES-256-GCM
Code to keyNot publishedArgon2id, about 0.7 s and 64 MiB
Forgotten codeReset with a code sent by email12-word recovery phrase
Lost email addressAccount and contents can’t be recoveredNo email involved
Who could access your filesKeepsafe, in limited cases it listsNobody without your pattern or phrase

Recovery shows the two philosophies well. Keepsafe’s PIN reset sends an access code to your verified email, which is convenient. But if you lose that address, Keepsafe says “it will not be possible to recover that Keepsafe account or its contents” (source). Sigilock gives each vault a 12-word recovery phrase instead: nothing to reset by email, but you have to keep the phrase safe yourself.

Decoys, intruders and disguises

Both apps can show a decoy when someone makes you open the vault. Keepsafe’s Decoy Vault is a second gallery opened with a different PIN, on Premium. In Sigilock, every pattern opens its own vault, so you can keep as many decoys as your plan allows, free.

Sigilock adds a duress mode, which Keepsafe doesn’t document: you choose a harmless vault as the duress vault, and opening it removes the other vaults’ patterns from the phone, so they can’t be opened there until you restore them with their recovery phrases. Keepsafe offers a face-down auto-lock instead, which locks the app when you put the phone face down.

For wrong guesses, Keepsafe’s Intruder Alerts take a secret photo of the person and log the time, on Premium. Sigilock’s intruder log records each failed attempt and when it happened, without taking photos, so it needs no camera permission for it. To disguise the app, Keepsafe’s Secret Door turns it into a calculator or virus scanner on Android only, on Premium; Keepsafe says it doesn’t exist on iPhone “due to Apple AppStore policy”. Sigilock’s calculator and notes icons work on both iPhone and Android, in the free plan.

Privacy: ads and data collected

Keepsafe Basic shows ads, and Premium removes them. Its App Store privacy label lists Usage Data under “Data Used to Track You”, and advertising data, not linked to you, used for third-party advertising. Its Google Play data safety section says it may collect data such as your email address, name, approximate location and app interactions, and may share purchase history, device IDs, user IDs and crash data for analytics. Its privacy policy describes interest-based advertising with partners.

Sigilock shows no ads and contains no analytics, crash reporting or advertising SDKs. How Sigilock avoids tracking lists the only things that ever leave your phone: purchases, through Apple or Google, and anything you choose to share or back up, encrypted.

Backup, sync and sharing

This is where Keepsafe’s account pays off. Sign in on another phone or tablet, on iPhone or Android, and your backed-up items appear there. Premium’s Space Saver keeps the originals in the cloud and lighter copies on the phone. Sigilock backs up each vault, if you choose, to your own iCloud on iPhone or a hidden folder in your own Google Drive on Android, and restores it with the recovery phrase; it doesn’t keep two devices in sync.

Both can share. Keepsafe’s Shared Albums work with invite links that expire after one use or 24 hours, and the people you invite create a Keepsafe account to join. Sigilock’s shared vaults are created with Premium and opened free with a phrase, with no account; they expire after at most 30 days, can limit how many times they open, and can be stopped at any time.

Where Keepsafe is better

  • iPad and sync. Apps for iPhone, iPad and Android, with your vault synced across all of them through your account.
  • Easy recovery. A forgotten PIN is reset with a code sent by email; there is no phrase to keep.
  • Intruder photos. A photo of whoever tried a wrong PIN, not just a log.
  • More storage for free. 200 backed-up items on Basic, against Sigilock’s 25 items in each of 2 vaults.
  • A long track record. On the market since the early 2010s, with tens of millions of users.
  • A trial and a monthly plan. 30 days of Premium to try, and a plan billed monthly.

Where Sigilock is better

  • No account. No email, no login and no server holding your photos or your keys.
  • No ads and no analytics. Nothing in the free plan or in Premium tracks what you do.
  • Every privacy feature for free. Decoys, duress mode, the intruder log and disguised icons are all in the free plan.
  • Duress mode. A harmless vault that, once opened, locks the others away.
  • A disguise on iPhone too. Calculator and notes icons on both platforms.
  • Published cryptography. AES-256-GCM and Argon2id, explained on the security page.

Switching from Keepsafe to Sigilock

  1. Install Sigilock and draw a sigil for your first vault. Write down its 12-word recovery phrase.
  2. In Keepsafe, select the photos and videos you want to move and export them. Keepsafe decrypts them back to your phone’s gallery.
  3. In Sigilock, tap Add and pick them. On iPhone, turn on Remove originals after import first and Sigilock offers to delete the copies; on Android, delete them in your gallery app yourself.
  4. Empty Recently Deleted (iPhone) or the trash in Google Photos (Android), so no copies stay behind.
  5. When everything is moved, cancel your Keepsafe subscription in the App Store or Google Play, and follow Keepsafe’s account deletion steps if you want its cloud copy removed.
  6. Our guides for iPhone and Android have more tips for leaving no copies behind.

Frequently asked questions

Does Keepsafe need an account?

Yes. Keepsafe asks you to create a login with a verified email address, which it uses for cloud backup, sync and PIN resets. Sigilock needs no account or email at all.

Can Keepsafe see my photos?

Keepsafe says it does not look at your content unless you ask, but that it is “not currently designed as a completely zero-knowledge app”, so it can technically access data for support, legal or terms-of-service reasons. Sigilock never has your keys, so it cannot open your vaults.

Is Keepsafe free?

Keepsafe Basic is free and ad-supported, with up to 200 items backed up to its cloud. Decoy vault, intruder alerts, Secret Door and ad-free use are Premium. Sigilock’s free plan has no ads and includes all its privacy features, with 2 vaults of 25 items.

Which one has a decoy vault?

Both. Keepsafe’s Decoy Vault is a second gallery behind a different PIN, on Premium. In Sigilock every pattern opens its own vault, free, and a duress vault can also lock the other vaults away.

What happens if I forget my code?

Keepsafe resets your PIN with a code sent to your verified email; if you lose access to that email, it says the account and its contents can’t be recovered. Sigilock opens a vault again with its 12-word recovery phrase.

Does Keepsafe work on iPhone and Android?

Yes, and on iPad too, with your vault synced through your Keepsafe account. Sigilock runs on iPhone and Android but has no iPad app or sync between devices yet.

Can I disguise the app on iPhone?

Keepsafe’s Secret Door disguise is Android only and Premium; Keepsafe says this is due to App Store policy. Sigilock offers calculator and notes icons on both iPhone and Android in its free plan.

How do I move my photos from Keepsafe to Sigilock?

Export them from Keepsafe back to your gallery, add them to a Sigilock vault, then delete the gallery copies and empty the trash. On iPhone, Sigilock can delete the copies for you.

Sources

Where the facts about each app on this page come from: their store listings, websites and policies, as checked on the date above.

  1. 1.App Store: Secret Photo Vault: Keepsafe
  2. 2.Google Play: Private Photo Vault - Keepsafe
  3. 3.Google Play: Keepsafe data safety
  4. 4.Keepsafe: Products
  5. 5.Keepsafe Help: Keepsafe Login
  6. 6.Keepsafe Help: How does Keepsafe protect my data?
  7. 7.Keepsafe Help: Can Keepsafe see any of my content?
  8. 8.Keepsafe Help: How does the Keepsafe backup work?
  9. 9.Keepsafe Help: What does Keepsafe Premium include?
  10. 10.Keepsafe Help: I lost my PIN code
  11. 11.Keepsafe Help: I lost access to my Keepsafe email address
  12. 12.Keepsafe Help: What is Secret Door?
  13. 13.Keepsafe Help: Shared Albums Overview
  14. 14.Keepsafe Help: What is the Premium trial?
  15. 15.Keepsafe Help: Permanently deleting your account
  16. 16.Keepsafe: Privacy policy